Download

The step by step guide to making an ICHRA sale

Sell ICHRA in four steps—qualify, pitch, close, hand off.
Download

Your Role: Getting Them to "Yes" and Through the Door

Your job ends when the client says yes and starts the signup process. Everything after that is handled by our teams - but knowing the full process helps you set expectations and close with confidence.

Phase 1: The Sale (That's You)

Your responsibility: Get them excited about ICHRA, align around a contribution amount they’re comfortable with, and guide them to signup.

Step 1: Qualify the Prospect

  • Use the "Who's a good fit for ICHRA?" framework
  • Your best bet for ICHRA will be people who fall into the Renewal Sticker Shock, New-to-Benefits Companies, or Micro Businesses personas

Step 2: Present the ICHRA Option

  • Use the 20-second elevator pitch: "ICHRA lets your company set a budget for employee health benefits while giving employees the freedom to choose individual insurance that works best for them"
  • Show pricing comparison vs. their current/quoted group plan
  • Address objections using the cheat sheet

Step 3: Quote and Close

  • Present contribution structure options (we recommend starting at 70-80% of current group premium costs)
  • Explain that employees get broker support for plan selection
  • Close: "I'll send you a link to get started. You can have this set up in about 10 minutes, and your team will have coverage options within 48 hours."

Step 4: Hand Off

  • Send them the Gallagher ICHRA portal signup link
  • Set the expectation: "StretchDollar's support team will walk you through setup - expect an email within 24 hours"
  • Your commission starts the month they go live

Phase 2: Admin Onboarding (StretchDollar Handles This)

Timeline: 3-5 business days

Your involvement: None - but here's what happens so you can answer questions

What the Employer Does:

  1. Signs ICHRA plan documents (handled digitally through portal)
  2. Connects their bank account for employee reimbursements
  3. Adds their employee roster (either via payroll integration or manual upload)
  4. Sets final contribution amounts per employee class

What StretchDollar Does:

  • Sends welcome email with setup instructions
  • Provides dedicated support rep for questions
  • Handles all compliance documentation
  • Sets up automated reimbursement system

Red flag: If you don't hear back from your client within a week of signup, ping Sheryl. Early onboarding issues are rare but easier to fix quickly.

Phase 3: Employee Onboarding (Automatic)

Timeline: Immediate once admin setup is complete

Your involvement: Zero

Employees Receive:

  • Email invitation to join their company's ICHRA
  • Link to add their bank account for reimbursements
  • Access to plan shopping portal

Three Ways Employees Get Coverage:

  1. Self-service shopping through the StretchDollar portal
  2. Schedule broker consultation for guided plan selection
  3. Call directly and get routed to a Gallagher ACA broker

Phase 4: Plan Matching & Enrollment (Gallagher ACA Team)

Timeline: Same day employee requests help

Revenue opportunity: You earn additional commission on every individual plan sold

How It Works:

  • Gallagher ACA team gets daily roster of employees needing assistance
  • Employees can book appointments, call in, or email for help
  • ACA team matches employees to best individual plan within their ICHRA contribution
  • You get broker of record commission on every policy written

What Success Looks Like

Week 1: Employer completes admin setup

Week 2: Employees start enrolling in individual plans

Month 1: You receive first ICHRA admin commission payment

Month 2+: Ongoing monthly commissions from both admin fees and individual plan commissions

When to Follow Up

  • Day 3: Quick check-in if they haven't started setup
  • Day 7: Escalate to Sheryl if no progress
  • Month 2: Touch base to see how rollout went (great time to ask for referrals)

Bottom line: Once you make the sale, our teams take over. Your job is to get them excited enough to start the process - we handle everything else.